Follow us on Twitter @claretandview // Words by Jake Evans (@jakeevans_11)

As we near the end of possibly the most tumultuous decade in our history – qualifying for Europe twice, beating Juventus (albeit in a Friendly), reaching the FA and League Cup Finals, going through ten managers & two owners, getting relegated, buying England legend John Terry, and losing a captain to leukaemia – we are putting down the best squad of players that have graced Villa Park in the last ten years… and giving you the chance to pick yours.


Brad Freidel
Brad Guzan
Shay Given
Sam Johnstone


Wilfred Bouma
Carlos Cuellar
Ryan Bertrand
Olof Mellberg
Martin Laursen
Ciaran Clark
Richard Dunne
Kyle Walker
Alan Hutton
Gary Cahill



Gareth Barry
Stiliyan Petrov
James Milner
Ashley Young
Fabian Delph
Barry Bannan
Marc Albrighton
Jack Grealish



John Carew
Gabriel Agbonlahor
Christian Benteke
Jonathan Kodjia
Emile Heskey
Andreas Weimann

After looking at the four pools, it is clear to see that, with just 28 players to choose from, there has not been a plethora of talent wearing a Villa shirt recently. Despite this, however, we think that a very good team can still be assembled. Here is what I have picked:

I have selected a simple 4-4-2 formation, managed by the Republic of Ireland boss Martin O’Neill. American Brad Friedel takes his unrivalled place between the sticks, while two of the best defenders in our history sit between the Spaniard Carlos Cuellar and the unfortunate Wilfred Bouma – a player who was once full of potential, but lost his way in the game after a horror injury not long into his Villa career. James Milner and Gareth Barry left Villa for Manchester City – but both return to this XI with ease, joining fellow Englishman Ashley Young in midfield. Our Captain, of course, is Bulgarian hero Stiliyan Petrov… no more needs to be said. Up front, I have selected John Carew and Christian Benteke – two goal machines that can be relied on to hit the back of the net on a regular basis. Just missing out is Gabriel Agbonlahor, who despite being our record goalscorer, just has not lived up to his potential. He would have taken the place of Benteke to recreate one of our most potent attacking duos… but he will have to make do with a place on a virtual bench, just like in real life, in fact.

Who makes your team? Comment below, or send a tweet @claretandview!

3 thoughts on “A Decade of Aston Villa – Who makes your best XI?”

  1. Brad Friedel between the sticks
    Laursen and Mellberg with Bouma and Clark
    Barry, Milner, Young, Petrov
    Carew and Bentekers

  2. Friedel
    Walker mellberg Laursen bertrand
    Downing milner petrov Barry young
    Strongest team to have played for villa.
    Would swap walker for Alan Hutton and Bertrand for bouma. Gabby and kodjia miss out but kodjia will soon be up there he’s so exciting to watch and love seeing him take on people.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.